 |
AirTalk.org
Aviation discussions newsgroups
|
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Kobra
Guest
|
 Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2007 6:11 am Post subject: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
 |
|
Flyers,
I was flying IFR in VFR conditions and from NJ to Kissimmee, FL (KISM). As
I was approaching KISM the controller asked if I wanted to do a visual
approach or the ILS. Since I was in unfamiliar surroundings and wanted to
practice an ILS I said, "I'll take the ILS."
As I waited for the typical clearance of, "Cessna XXX, 5 miles from XYZ, fly
heading 180, maintain 2000 until established, cleared for the ILS XX
approach." I got, "Ok, just let me know when you want to start the
approach."
Huh!?! I didn't know what to do or say. I asked, "Do you want me to head
for the FAF?" Then another controller came on the frequency and said,
"Cessna XXX cleared for the ILS approach"
So I just headed for the FAF and began to intercept the localizer. The
controller than asked me what I was doing. I was so confused since they
were not using standard terminology. Thoughts anyone.
Kobra |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
David Cartwright
Guest
|
| Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2007 2:43 pm Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
"Kobra" <kobra (AT) yahoo (DOT) net> wrote in message
news:y8-dnX8vz6k4sK3bnZ2dnUVZ_uOmnZ2d (AT) comcast (DOT) com...
| Quote: | As I waited for the typical clearance of, "Cessna XXX, 5 miles from XYZ,
fly heading 180, maintain 2000 until established, cleared for the ILS XX
approach." I got, "Ok, just let me know when you want to start the
approach."
|
Sounds like it was a pretty quiet day and as a result he was being rather
too informal.
I would interpret the controller's instruction as meaning that you're VFR,
and so he's expecting you to make whatever calls VFR requires (e.g. calling
on final for clearance to land). The fact that you're intending to get there
via a route that happens to coincide with the ILS is entirely
circumstantial.
Over the years I've had a lot of informal instructions/comments from ATC,
though generally it's been informal but useful. (e.g. Me: "Blah blah request
joining instructions; please confirm runway in use 27"; Them: "Join however
you want, let me know which runway you'd like though"), though as my local
airfield has become more and more busy with commercial traffic, this is
rarely the case these days. Personally, I prefer it formal; the words to be
spoken have been designed for a very good reason (i.e. to keep them clear
and unambiguous, and thus promote safety) and so they should be used as
such - particularly when informal instructions of the sort that you describe
don't tell you what you actually wanted in the first place.
D. |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
Steven P. McNicoll
Guest
|
| Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2007 3:19 pm Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
"Kobra" <kobra (AT) yahoo (DOT) net> wrote in message
news:y8-dnX8vz6k4sK3bnZ2dnUVZ_uOmnZ2d (AT) comcast (DOT) com...
| Quote: |
I was flying IFR in VFR conditions and from NJ to Kissimmee, FL (KISM).
As I was approaching KISM the controller asked if I wanted to do a visual
approach or the ILS. Since I was in unfamiliar surroundings and wanted to
practice an ILS I said, "I'll take the ILS."
As I waited for the typical clearance of, "Cessna XXX, 5 miles from XYZ,
fly heading 180, maintain 2000 until established, cleared for the ILS XX
approach." I got, "Ok, just let me know when you want to start the
approach."
Huh!?! I didn't know what to do or say. I asked, "Do you want me to head
for the FAF?" Then another controller came on the frequency and said,
"Cessna XXX cleared for the ILS approach"
So I just headed for the FAF and began to intercept the localizer. The
controller than asked me what I was doing. I was so confused since they
were not using standard terminology. Thoughts anyone.
|
Did your enroute routing take you over an IAF or feeder fix? If so, you
should have just flown the previously assigned route until you were on a
published segment of the ILS approach. You can begin descent to the
published altitude for the route segment at your discretion. |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
bsalai
Guest
|
| Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2007 3:25 pm Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
Kobra wrote:
| Quote: | Flyers,
I was flying IFR in VFR conditions and from NJ to Kissimmee, FL (KISM). As
I was approaching KISM the controller asked if I wanted to do a visual
approach or the ILS. Since I was in unfamiliar surroundings and wanted to
practice an ILS I said, "I'll take the ILS."
As I waited for the typical clearance of, "Cessna XXX, 5 miles from XYZ, fly
heading 180, maintain 2000 until established, cleared for the ILS XX
approach." I got, "Ok, just let me know when you want to start the
approach."
Huh!?! I didn't know what to do or say. I asked, "Do you want me to head
for the FAF?" Then another controller came on the frequency and said,
"Cessna XXX cleared for the ILS approach"
So I just headed for the FAF and began to intercept the localizer. The
controller than asked me what I was doing. I was so confused since they
were not using standard terminology. Thoughts anyone.
Kobra
I'm not an expert, but I think they expected you to fly to the IAF and |
fly the full approach. This is very standard, but a bit unusual, since
mostly you get vectors to final, but actually, vectors are the special
case, a full approach is more "standard" that is, it is what you should
expect, and what you should fly if you don't get special instructions,
ie. vectors.
Brad |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
Matt Whiting
Guest
|
| Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2007 3:45 pm Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
Kobra wrote:
| Quote: | Flyers,
I was flying IFR in VFR conditions and from NJ to Kissimmee, FL (KISM). As
I was approaching KISM the controller asked if I wanted to do a visual
approach or the ILS. Since I was in unfamiliar surroundings and wanted to
practice an ILS I said, "I'll take the ILS."
As I waited for the typical clearance of, "Cessna XXX, 5 miles from XYZ, fly
heading 180, maintain 2000 until established, cleared for the ILS XX
approach." I got, "Ok, just let me know when you want to start the
approach."
Huh!?! I didn't know what to do or say. I asked, "Do you want me to head
for the FAF?" Then another controller came on the frequency and said,
"Cessna XXX cleared for the ILS approach"
So I just headed for the FAF and began to intercept the localizer. The
controller than asked me what I was doing. I was so confused since they
were not using standard terminology. Thoughts anyone.
Kobra
|
Trainee controller. We have them a lot at ELM also.
Matt |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
Matt Whiting
Guest
|
| Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2007 3:52 pm Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
Kobra wrote:
| Quote: | Flyers,
I was flying IFR in VFR conditions and from NJ to Kissimmee, FL (KISM). As
I was approaching KISM the controller asked if I wanted to do a visual
approach or the ILS. Since I was in unfamiliar surroundings and wanted to
practice an ILS I said, "I'll take the ILS."
As I waited for the typical clearance of, "Cessna XXX, 5 miles from XYZ, fly
heading 180, maintain 2000 until established, cleared for the ILS XX
approach." I got, "Ok, just let me know when you want to start the
approach."
Huh!?! I didn't know what to do or say. I asked, "Do you want me to head
for the FAF?" Then another controller came on the frequency and said,
"Cessna XXX cleared for the ILS approach"
So I just headed for the FAF and began to intercept the localizer. The
controller than asked me what I was doing. I was so confused since they
were not using standard terminology. Thoughts anyone.
|
Confusion is bad so whenever I'm confused I generally do one of two things:
1. Call ATC and tell them I don't understand their instruction and ask
them what they really want me to do.
2. State clearly what I plan to do and then do it if I don't hear
anything to the contrary.
In your case, #1 might be: "Approach, verify that Cessna XXX is cleared
for a full ILS YY approach." I'm trusting that as an instrument rated
pilot you know what a full approach means.
#2 might have been: "Approach, Cessna XXX is flying present position to
the FAF for ILS YY and will fly inbound upon interception."
Matt |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
Dave Butler
Guest
|
| Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2007 4:04 pm Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
Kobra wrote:
| Quote: | Flyers,
I was flying IFR in VFR conditions and from NJ to Kissimmee, FL (KISM). As
I was approaching KISM the controller asked if I wanted to do a visual
approach or the ILS. Since I was in unfamiliar surroundings and wanted to
practice an ILS I said, "I'll take the ILS."
As I waited for the typical clearance of, "Cessna XXX, 5 miles from XYZ, fly
heading 180, maintain 2000 until established, cleared for the ILS XX
approach." I got, "Ok, just let me know when you want to start the
approach."
Huh!?! I didn't know what to do or say. I asked, "Do you want me to head
for the FAF?" Then another controller came on the frequency and said,
"Cessna XXX cleared for the ILS approach"
So I just headed for the FAF and began to intercept the localizer. The
controller than asked me what I was doing. I was so confused since they
were not using standard terminology. Thoughts anyone.
|
Assuming the approach in question is the ILS 15 at KISM
http://204.108.4.16/d-tpp/0704/05793IL15.PDF the approach is RADAR
REQUIRED and has no IAFs. The clearance "cleared for the approach" with
no vector is defective. With that clearance, you should head for the IAF
of your choice for a "full" approach, but there is no IAF. You can only
get vectors. |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
Dave Butler
Guest
|
| Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2007 4:06 pm Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
| Quote: |
I would interpret the controller's instruction as meaning that you're VFR,
and so he's expecting you to make whatever calls VFR requires (e.g. calling
on final for clearance to land). The fact that you're intending to get there
via a route that happens to coincide with the ILS is entirely
circumstantial.
|
He said he was IFR. |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
Ron Rosenfeld
Guest
|
| Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2007 4:50 pm Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
On Thu, 26 Apr 2007 00:42:17 -0400, "Kobra" <kobra (AT) yahoo (DOT) net> wrote:
| Quote: | Flyers,
I was flying IFR in VFR conditions and from NJ to Kissimmee, FL (KISM). As
I was approaching KISM the controller asked if I wanted to do a visual
approach or the ILS. Since I was in unfamiliar surroundings and wanted to
practice an ILS I said, "I'll take the ILS."
As I waited for the typical clearance of, "Cessna XXX, 5 miles from XYZ, fly
heading 180, maintain 2000 until established, cleared for the ILS XX
approach." I got, "Ok, just let me know when you want to start the
approach."
Huh!?! I didn't know what to do or say. I asked, "Do you want me to head
for the FAF?" Then another controller came on the frequency and said,
"Cessna XXX cleared for the ILS approach"
So I just headed for the FAF and began to intercept the localizer. The
controller than asked me what I was doing. I was so confused since they
were not using standard terminology. Thoughts anyone.
Kobra
|
It sounds to me like a bogus clearance.
This seems to be an approach with no IAF (at least on the Jepp chart),
implying to me that you should have been receiving vectors to final.
Perhaps the controller taking over thought that controller #1 had given you
vectors to the final approach course, and was confused by your turning of
what he thought was a vector.
Ron (EPM) (N5843Q, Mooney M20E) (CP, ASEL, ASES, IA) |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
Guest
|
| Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2007 6:29 pm Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
Here's a rule to follow:
When you want an instrument approach, tell the controller, EVERY TIME:
a) Which approach you want (use complete title e.g., ILS RWY 6)
b) Whether you want vectors, or wish to start at an IAF,
c) in the case of the latter, WHICH IAF you wish to start at, if there
is more than one.
Gets you and the controller on the same page right away. If he can't
oblige your request, he'll work out another.
There is NO REASON to start an approach without this understanding.
By the way, why would you ever head for the FAF to begin an approach?
No approaches ever start at the FAF.
On Thu, 26 Apr 2007 00:42:17 -0400, "Kobra" <kobra (AT) yahoo (DOT) net> wrote:
| Quote: | Flyers,
I was flying IFR in VFR conditions and from NJ to Kissimmee, FL (KISM). As
I was approaching KISM the controller asked if I wanted to do a visual
approach or the ILS. Since I was in unfamiliar surroundings and wanted to
practice an ILS I said, "I'll take the ILS."
As I waited for the typical clearance of, "Cessna XXX, 5 miles from XYZ, fly
heading 180, maintain 2000 until established, cleared for the ILS XX
approach." I got, "Ok, just let me know when you want to start the
approach."
Huh!?! I didn't know what to do or say. I asked, "Do you want me to head
for the FAF?" Then another controller came on the frequency and said,
"Cessna XXX cleared for the ILS approach"
So I just headed for the FAF and began to intercept the localizer. The
controller than asked me what I was doing. I was so confused since they
were not using standard terminology. Thoughts anyone.
Kobra
|
|
|
| Back to top |
|
|
JB
Guest
|
| Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2007 6:29 pm Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
On Apr 26, 12:42 am, "Kobra" <k...@yahoo.net> wrote:
| Quote: | Flyers,
I was flying IFR in VFR conditions and from NJ to Kissimmee, FL (KISM). As
I was approaching KISM the controller asked if I wanted to do a visual
approach or the ILS. Since I was in unfamiliar surroundings and wanted to
practice an ILS I said, "I'll take the ILS."
As I waited for the typical clearance of, "Cessna XXX, 5 miles from XYZ, fly
heading 180, maintain 2000 until established, cleared for the ILS XX
approach." I got, "Ok, just let me know when you want to start the
approach."
Huh!?! I didn't know what to do or say. I asked, "Do you want me to head
for the FAF?" Then another controller came on the frequency and said,
"Cessna XXX cleared for the ILS approach"
So I just headed for the FAF and began to intercept the localizer. The
controller than asked me what I was doing. I was so confused since they
were not using standard terminology. Thoughts anyone.
Kobra
|
When I am doing practices approaches in my local area, I sometimes get
asked where I want to begin the approach (from an official IAF or an
intermediate fix via radar vectors). I have never heard what you
describe, but when I am AT ALL confused or uncertain what the
controller expects, I always say where I'd like to begin the approach.
In your case, and to avoid ANY confusion, I probably would have
followed up with "Approach, Cessna XXXX would like to begin the KISM
ILS at XYZ. Can I get radar vectors to that point?"
--Jeff |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
JB
Guest
|
| Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2007 7:23 pm Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
On Apr 26, 12:42 am, "Kobra" <k...@yahoo.net> wrote:
| Quote: | Flyers,
I was flying IFR in VFR conditions and from NJ to Kissimmee, FL (KISM). As
I was approaching KISM the controller asked if I wanted to do a visual
approach or the ILS. Since I was in unfamiliar surroundings and wanted to
practice an ILS I said, "I'll take the ILS."
As I waited for the typical clearance of, "Cessna XXX, 5 miles from XYZ, fly
heading 180, maintain 2000 until established, cleared for the ILS XX
approach." I got, "Ok, just let me know when you want to start the
approach."
Huh!?! I didn't know what to do or say. I asked, "Do you want me to head
for the FAF?" Then another controller came on the frequency and said,
"Cessna XXX cleared for the ILS approach"
So I just headed for the FAF and began to intercept the localizer. The
controller than asked me what I was doing. I was so confused since they
were not using standard terminology. Thoughts anyone.
Kobra
|
When I do practice approaches in my local area (VFR or IFR), I often
get asked by the controller where I want to begin the approach (an
official IAF or radar vector to some intermediate point). Whenever
I'm not 110% sure the controller and I have the same expectations, I
always transmit that "Piper XXXX would like to begin the approach at
XYZ."
I have never heard what you describe. But in your case, and to avoid
ANY misunderstanding of what happens next, I would have responded
"Cessna XXXX is ready to begin the KISM ILS approach and would like to
start at XYZ. Can you provide radar vectors?" I would not just "head
for" the FAF without response from the controller.
--Jeff |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
Barney Rubble
Guest
|
| Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2007 9:55 pm Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
You should have asked for the full ILS with vectors to the IAF/FAF or
specified the IAF if not RV. Just because the controller is being informal,
doesn't mean you have to. I had a similar experience at KCLL once, it leaves
you wondering WTF you did wrong....
"Kobra" <kobra (AT) yahoo (DOT) net> wrote in message
news:y8-dnX8vz6k4sK3bnZ2dnUVZ_uOmnZ2d (AT) comcast (DOT) com...
| Quote: | Flyers,
I was flying IFR in VFR conditions and from NJ to Kissimmee, FL (KISM).
As I was approaching KISM the controller asked if I wanted to do a visual
approach or the ILS. Since I was in unfamiliar surroundings and wanted to
practice an ILS I said, "I'll take the ILS."
As I waited for the typical clearance of, "Cessna XXX, 5 miles from XYZ,
fly heading 180, maintain 2000 until established, cleared for the ILS XX
approach." I got, "Ok, just let me know when you want to start the
approach."
Huh!?! I didn't know what to do or say. I asked, "Do you want me to head
for the FAF?" Then another controller came on the frequency and said,
"Cessna XXX cleared for the ILS approach"
So I just headed for the FAF and began to intercept the localizer. The
controller than asked me what I was doing. I was so confused since they
were not using standard terminology. Thoughts anyone.
Kobra
|
|
|
| Back to top |
|
|
Kobra
Guest
|
| Posted: Fri Apr 27, 2007 2:30 am Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
| Quote: | Did your enroute routing take you over an IAF or feeder fix? If so, you
should have just flown the previously assigned route until you were on a
published segment of the ILS approach.
|
Steve, I think you are correct. There was no IAF on the plate, but I did
have an assigned heading of 180 from a while back. Once the second
controller cleared me for the approach (as unorthodox as his verbology was)
I probably should have just stayed on a 180 heading until I intercepted the
approach course and then began my descent for glide slope intercept. It was
the unusual way in which I was handled that threw me off.
The only time I've ever heard someone ask for "the full approach" was if it
was NOT Radar Required and there was some sort of course reversal involved
that they wanted to practice.
I just expected to hear, "Ok, Cessna 07G continue heading 180, maintain 2000
until established, cleared for the ILS 15 approach." When I didn't receive
a heading I incorrectly assumed I could fly whatever heading I needed to
intercept the approach course at or prior to the FAF. Technically, I was
given a heading. It was 180. That was my last clearance and no one changed
it so I should have flown my last assigned heading. As others have said,
once I was confused as to the clearance I should have started asking
questions or for clarifications.
Thanks for all your help out there.
Kobra |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
Newps
Guest
|
| Posted: Fri Apr 27, 2007 2:44 am Post subject: Re: Anyone ever hear this from a controller |
|
|
Matt Whiting wrote:
| Quote: |
Trainee controller. We have them a lot at ELM also.
|
A trainee controller has the experienced one sitting right next to him.
Some information is missing. |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|
FAQ
Search
Memberlist
Usergroups
Register
Profile
Log in to check your private messages
Log in
