AirTalk.org Forum Index AirTalk.org
Aviation discussions newsgroups
 
Archives   FAQFAQ   SearchSearch   MemberlistMemberlist   UsergroupsUsergroups   RegisterRegister 
 ProfileProfile   Log in to check your private messagesLog in to check your private messages   Log inLog in 

Ground shyness?
Goto page 1, 2  Next
 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    AirTalk.org Forum Index -> Aviation (Students)
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Bryan Mason
Guest





PostPosted: Wed Oct 20, 2004 4:10 pm    Post subject: Ground shyness? Reply with quote



Hi all,

I'm nearing the 20 hour mark and am working on landings (well, they're
supposed to be landings but . . . well . . . lets just say I'm
thankful for sturdy landing gear).

I'm getting better at sideslipping during descent, but my instructor
and I have noticed some things that I'm doing on landing that are
really messing things up.

1) Too slow on approach (tendency to pull the yoke back as I get
closer to the ground).
2) Pulling back quickly on the level-off, causing a flare way too
early, with the resulting fun that happens after that.
3) Ending up on the left side of the runway and many times yawing to
the left.

I'm thinking that maybe 1 and 2 is caused by ground shyness. With the
nose down on what would probably be a proper approach, as we get down
close to the ground, it feels like I'm going to ram the nose of the
airplane into the ground. I know that I'm not (at least I know my
instructor will intervene before it gets to that point), but it makes
me very nervous. I'm unconciously pulling back on the yoke and don't
notice it until my instructor says "too slow -- nose down."

Anybody have any hints -- mental tricks if you will -- to get over
ground shyness. Or is it just do it over and over and I'll get used
to it.

Also, anybody have any idea about #3. It seems like I'm lined up and
everything, and next thing I know, I'm on the left side of the runway
again.

For the record, I'm flying a Piper Warrior II.
Back to top
Mark Hansen
Guest





PostPosted: Wed Oct 20, 2004 4:48 pm    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote



On 10/20/2004 09:10, Bryan Mason <bmason
Quote:
Hi all,

I'm nearing the 20 hour mark and am working on landings (well, they're
supposed to be landings but . . . well . . . lets just say I'm
thankful for sturdy landing gear).

My CFI calls this "landing within mechanical tolerances" ;-)

Quote:

I'm getting better at sideslipping during descent, but my instructor
and I have noticed some things that I'm doing on landing that are
really messing things up.

1) Too slow on approach (tendency to pull the yoke back as I get
closer to the ground).

Normal.

Quote:
2) Pulling back quickly on the level-off, causing a flare way too
early, with the resulting fun that happens after that.

Normal.

Quote:
3) Ending up on the left side of the runway and many times yawing to
the left.

This is just a result of being too busy at this stage of the
landing, and not having the corrections coming automatically.
This will improve with practice.

Quote:

I'm thinking that maybe 1 and 2 is caused by ground shyness. With the
nose down on what would probably be a proper approach, as we get down
close to the ground, it feels like I'm going to ram the nose of the
airplane into the ground. I know that I'm not (at least I know my
instructor will intervene before it gets to that point), but it makes
me very nervous. I'm unconciously pulling back on the yoke and don't
notice it until my instructor says "too slow -- nose down."

Yes, this is normal. When I was first learning to land, I would
pull-up too soon and get yelled at. On the next landing, I would
try to let it go longer, and get yelled at for flying right into
the ground. I would swear there was no middle ground - but of course,
there is.

Quote:

Anybody have any hints -- mental tricks if you will -- to get over
ground shyness. Or is it just do it over and over and I'll get used
to it.

One way to help with this problem is to improve the glide to the
runway. By that I mean don't end up too high such that you have
to dive to the runway. If you can maintain a nice even glide to
the runway, then the round-out requires much less of a control
movement.

Otherwise, you just have to try to learn when is the right time to
begin the round-out, and work at not starting it too early or making
them too abruptly. This will come with time.

Quote:

Also, anybody have any idea about #3. It seems like I'm lined up and
everything, and next thing I know, I'm on the left side of the runway
again.

Yes. You're too busy to notice the plane floating to the left.
With practice, you'll find that the rudder actions and aileron
actions will happen automatically, each as needed to its particular
job.

The best you can do is correct for it as soon as you notice it,
and before too long, you'll find that your drift gets smaller
and smaller.

Quote:

For the record, I'm flying a Piper Warrior II.

Good luck and don't get too frustrated. You'll get through it, as
have many others before you.


Back to top
Gary Drescher
Guest





PostPosted: Wed Oct 20, 2004 5:20 pm    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote



"Bryan Mason bmason com>" <bmason
Quote:
With the
nose down on what would probably be a proper approach, as we get down
close to the ground, it feels like I'm going to ram the nose of the
airplane into the ground. I know that I'm not (at least I know my
instructor will intervene before it gets to that point), but it makes
me very nervous. I'm unconciously pulling back on the yoke and don't
notice it until my instructor says "too slow -- nose down."

Anybody have any hints -- mental tricks if you will -- to get over
ground shyness. Or is it just do it over and over and I'll get used
to it.

I had the same difficulty at the same point in my training. My instructor
repeated "keep the nose down" so often that (after I eventually got it right
and soloed) I could hear his admonition even when he wasn't there (which was
a helpful reminder).

Yes, repetition will eventually solve the problem. But there are a couple of
things that might speed the process. One trick is to cut power gradually
rather than abruptly when you get close to the runway. That way, you keep
your descent more constant, and let things happen a bit more slowly. Another
trick (if you've got a long runway) is to pick a landing spot a good
distance from the threshold, so you don't get anxious about feeling too
close to the ground when you're not even over the runway yet.

A third trick is to find a *very* long runway and just cruise down most of
it a foot above ground, to get used to what it looks like to be flying very
close to the runway. Ordinarily, when you practice landings, you spend an
hour or so hundreds of feet above ground, and only a few seconds at a time
close to the ground. If you can spend almost a minute close to the ground in
a single low approach, you get as much near-ground experience as from a
dozen landings.

Good luck!

--Gary



Back to top
kontiki
Guest





PostPosted: Wed Oct 20, 2004 6:37 pm    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote

Keep flying the airplane all the way. It's not uncommon that
students forget about flying the aiplane when they are close
to the ground... hoping things will sort of work out. Keep
flying it until you are into ground effect then ease off the
throttle as you shift your gaze to the far end of the runway.
Try to "keep it flying" with the power off it until it will
tend to gracefully settle itself onto the runway.

Later when you have to land in windy/gusty conditions you'll
have to modify the amount of power you use (or ease off) as
you get close to the runway in order to maintain more positive
control, but that will come in time.

Back to top
C J Campbell
Guest





PostPosted: Wed Oct 20, 2004 7:25 pm    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote

We call it "fear of runway." (I don't know what phobia that is; whatever the
Greek word is for runway + phobia, suppose.) Anyway, it goes away with time
and practice.


Back to top
Brien K. Meehan
Guest





PostPosted: Wed Oct 20, 2004 8:16 pm    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote

Bryan Mason wrote:
Quote:
I'm getting better at sideslipping during descent ...

Would you clarify this point? Are you slipping on final during a
normal landing, every time?


Back to top
Bryan Mason
Guest





PostPosted: Wed Oct 20, 2004 9:59 pm    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote

On 20 Oct 2004 13:16:27 -0700, "Brien K. Meehan"
<brien (AT) networkgenius (DOT) com> wrote:

Quote:
Bryan Mason wrote:
I'm getting better at sideslipping during descent ...

Would you clarify this point? Are you slipping on final during a
normal landing, every time?

Not every time. just when there's enough crosswind to justify it.
I'm starting to slideslip much earlier than I should, mostly to get
the hang of it.

What I really should have said is that I'm getting better at using the
rudder to make sure that the nose points down the runway. During my
first attempts at a final approach, the nose was swinging all over the
place. Now it's more stable.

-- Bryan


Back to top
mhquay
Guest





PostPosted: Wed Oct 20, 2004 10:15 pm    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote


From one student pilot (just over 40 hours) to another.

I am sure every pilot has this fear when close to the ground and I
would bet that many licensed pilots probably have an increase in
heart-rate when landing as well.

There is only one fix.... Lots of practice.

The more landings you do the more relaxed you will become. This will
also solve your other landing problems as you will be able to "feel"
the time to flare and will perform the manouvre with finesse rather
than jerky movements and will notice drift etc earlier and be able to
apply the appropriate correction.

Remember that the landing procedure starts when you join the circuit.
Get your airspeed, attitude and trim right on base and final and the
aircraft will do most of the work for you.
My father-in-law (40 years experience) told me, when I started
learning. not to forget that the aircraft is just a machine and you are
the boss. If it wants to drift or sink don't let it!

Good Luck.

Phil


--
mhquay
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted via OziPilots Online [ http://www.OziPilotsOnline.com.au ]
- A website for Australian Pilots regardless of when, why, or what they fly -

Back to top
BTIZ
Guest





PostPosted: Wed Oct 20, 2004 11:19 pm    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote

have the instructor get you down to about 5ft above the runway at approach
speed and apply enough power to fly the length of the runway.. concentrate
on maintaining the set altitude and the centerline.. do it 3 to 4 times.. a
little lower each time.. then it's just a matter of losing that last 1ft of
altitude and pulling the power back to land..

just a thought

BT

"Bryan Mason bmason com>" <bmason
Quote:
Hi all,

I'm nearing the 20 hour mark and am working on landings (well, they're
supposed to be landings but . . . well . . . lets just say I'm
thankful for sturdy landing gear).

I'm getting better at sideslipping during descent, but my instructor
and I have noticed some things that I'm doing on landing that are
really messing things up.

1) Too slow on approach (tendency to pull the yoke back as I get
closer to the ground).
2) Pulling back quickly on the level-off, causing a flare way too
early, with the resulting fun that happens after that.
3) Ending up on the left side of the runway and many times yawing to
the left.

I'm thinking that maybe 1 and 2 is caused by ground shyness. With the
nose down on what would probably be a proper approach, as we get down
close to the ground, it feels like I'm going to ram the nose of the
airplane into the ground. I know that I'm not (at least I know my
instructor will intervene before it gets to that point), but it makes
me very nervous. I'm unconciously pulling back on the yoke and don't
notice it until my instructor says "too slow -- nose down."

Anybody have any hints -- mental tricks if you will -- to get over
ground shyness. Or is it just do it over and over and I'll get used
to it.

Also, anybody have any idea about #3. It seems like I'm lined up and
everything, and next thing I know, I'm on the left side of the runway
again.

For the record, I'm flying a Piper Warrior II.



Back to top
Chris
Guest





PostPosted: Thu Oct 21, 2004 12:51 am    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote

Quote:
3) Ending up on the left side of the runway and many times yawing to
the left.

My wife had the same problem. Our instructor thought she was looking
across the nose of the plane and lining up based on seeing from that
angle ..whoosh off to the left everytime. She learned to look straight
out of the windshield rather than lining up the nose with the center
line. Landed correctly once, never landed left again.

I had about 225 landings by the time I passed my PPL. I love landing.
I have a Piper 140 with the Hershey Bar wings.

Chris

Back to top
Pavan Bhatnagar
Guest





PostPosted: Thu Oct 21, 2004 5:09 am    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote

Bryan Mason <bmason wrote


Hi Bryan - you have already identified the reason for 1 & 2.

Point 3 - ending up on the left - is likely because you are trying to
put the centerline *between* yourself & the instructor.
Don't do that - aim to put *yourself* over the centerline.
I'm sure a quick think will self-illumibate the reason for this :)

best
Pavan.

Quote:

1) Too slow on approach (tendency to pull the yoke back as I get
closer to the ground).
2) Pulling back quickly on the level-off, causing a flare way too
early, with the resulting fun that happens after that.
3) Ending up on the left side of the runway and many times yawing to
the left.


Back to top
Jay Beckman
Guest





PostPosted: Thu Oct 21, 2004 7:26 am    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote

"Bryan Mason bmason com>" <bmason
Quote:
Hi all,

I'm nearing the 20 hour mark and am working on landings (well, they're
supposed to be landings but . . . well . . . lets just say I'm
thankful for sturdy landing gear).

I'm getting better at sideslipping during descent, but my instructor
and I have noticed some things that I'm doing on landing that are
really messing things up.

1) Too slow on approach (tendency to pull the yoke back as I get
closer to the ground).
2) Pulling back quickly on the level-off, causing a flare way too
early, with the resulting fun that happens after that.
3) Ending up on the left side of the runway and many times yawing to
the left.

I'm thinking that maybe 1 and 2 is caused by ground shyness. With the
nose down on what would probably be a proper approach, as we get down
close to the ground, it feels like I'm going to ram the nose of the
airplane into the ground. I know that I'm not (at least I know my
instructor will intervene before it gets to that point), but it makes
me very nervous. I'm unconciously pulling back on the yoke and don't
notice it until my instructor says "too slow -- nose down."


Three major breakthroughs helped me make better landings:

1) I was able to minimize as many variables as possible when I finally
learned to appreciate the value of a solid, stabilized approach. I suffered
through my fair share of poor landings becuase my biggest flaw was too fast
over the fence. I'd either float forever and rush to set the plane down
(usually at too flat an angle = boing, boing, boing...) or I'd over rotate
in the flare, balloon like crazy, and drop it in in ugly fashion.

Once I began to get a handle on the relationship between pitch and power,
and I was able to nail down a more sedate and consistant airspeed on final,
I was able to make much better landings in terms of the quality of the
actual touchdown. Now it's almost second nature to pull off a couple
hundred RPMs or pitch up or down a little to make subtle corrections in my
flight path. The suggestion about making some low approaches without
actually touching down, is great advice. Try it, it's fun!!

2) As for the alignment thing, the advice one of the other posters offered
helped me too: Try and put the centerline right between your legs on
landing. I was out one day with my CFI and I happened to mention to him
that I noticed my landings were generally left of center. His Zen-like
advice? "Well then, try doing something different!" On my next few landings
and pretty much ever since, I try to sit on the centerline and more often
than not, even if I'm not perfect, I'll get the centerline between the
mains.

3) I went through a spate of landings around my 12th hour or so that were
characterized by rather dramatic changes in heading just about the time the
nosewheel came in contact with pavement. It was a textbook case of relaxing
too soon, becoming a passive "passenger" and not being the pilot *in
command* all the way to the ramp. I went out one day and made eight
full-stop / taxi-back landings in a row and it sure sharpened my awareness
of how the dynamics change during the transition from AIR-plane to
GROUND-plane. My mantra is now "Fly the plane, don't let the plane fly
you!!"

Quote:

Anybody have any hints -- mental tricks if you will -- to get over
ground shyness. Or is it just do it over and over and I'll get used
to it.


Repetition helps, so long as it isn't reinforcing bad habits (but your
instructor should be able to nip bad habits in the bud and help you beat
them into submission.) Sometimes, a second opinion is a good thing. I
actually asked another instructor to ride with me one time when I thought
I'd hit a "wall" in my training. He offered a thought or two which I was
able to put to good use.

Keep after it...I know from my own training experience that you will
eventually enjoy a moment of clarity and all the pieces will quickly begin
to fall into place!

Good Luck and report back often.

Jay Beckman
Chandler, AZ
PP-ASEL
Still nowhere to go but up!



Back to top
Pete
Guest





PostPosted: Thu Oct 21, 2004 8:01 am    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote

I'm sure the professionals on here will have some expert advice on
this but the following are things I look out for.

- A good set up on turning crosswind and on to finals really helps.
Getting the airspeed right at these points certainly helps lead
towards a good landing. Agree the right airspeed with the instructor
(and instruction book).

- The transition from coming in on the landing to going parallel with
the runway (the flare) is the trickiest bit for me. I've focused on it
being a more gradual transition rather than switching from state A to
state B immediately. Shifting gaze to the end of the runway enables me
to see my attitude better. Looking at the end of the runway I can
assess if I'm raising or falling in height. The aim being to fly
parallel for as long as possible without actually landing. As I sense
I'm loosing height I pull back on the stick, but not enough to start
taking off again. If I sense I'm going to take off again (cause I
pulled back to much) I'll keep the stick still before commencing to
pull back more and more.

- When everything is right you'll be pulling further and further back
with the stall warner sounding and you'll avoid the landing on three
wheels.

- Sitting in the aircraft and just learning the attitude it sits on
the tarmac helps you recognise the attitude you should be looking for
during the landing, but slightly nose up of course.

- When you do pull back too much and balloon, hold the stick still but
make judgment as to whether more throttle is required to stop hitting
the runway hard and turning into a bouncer.

- Making sure the throttle is fully back is important.

I'm certainly no expert and look forward to others comments on this so
I too can hopefully make that lovely soft landing more often
Back to top
Dave
Guest





PostPosted: Thu Oct 21, 2004 12:22 pm    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote

Bryan,

I am getting to the solo point myself and the landings are out of the way
pretty much. I fly a Cessna so this may be a moot point, and I acknowledge
that my issues may not be the same as you describe, but maybe this helps. I
had the same problems under two conditions.

1. When I was descending towards a point that I thought was the _before_ the
threshold of the runway (the Numbers). When I got real close it became more
apparent that I was not going to make the runway at my current rate of
decent and the first reaction was to lift the nose. That of course has been
dealt with by using and trusting the method of halting or slowing the decent
with more power.
I don't know about your airport but the runways at mine have the ILS aiming
point painted on them. I now set my own personal aiming point 1/4 of the
way up from the numbers as referenced by the ILS aiming point.
This gives me the comfort zone of not having to worry so much about not
making the runway at all. I use the freed up "brain cycles" to get a nice
looking decent instead of worrying about dropping it in on the Parkway.

And I say "Nice looking decent" because I can maneuver the plane in such a
way that I don't need to cut power and drop the nose to start the landing.
And that brings me to point two

2. My instructor had me practice landings by descending to 400feet, using
power to level off at 400 feet then get up to the threshold and cut the
power.
Well that was fun but I had to figure out on my own that you don't have to
be so high all the time over the threshold or always cut the power and drop
that nose every time. The idea is to use all the knowledge to make a
landing. So now I have a nice decent set up so that I don't get too low,
that also doesn't require such a dramatic nose down final. I gently roll
off the power and I can "feel" the flare. I don't know if this makes sense
or not; quickly cutting the power requires a quick nose down. A more gentle
power cut and I am with the flare all the way. Maybe it's just me.

Lastly, I believe that I have subconsciously been doing something that
another poster said in this thread. That is looking beyond the nose of the
aircraft to keep the runway centered. Looking beyond the nose will also
keep you from drawing the imaginary line that points straight through the
nose in into the ground.


--
Dave A
Aging Student Pilot
KFRG

"Bryan Mason bmason com>" <bmason
Quote:
Hi all,

I'm nearing the 20 hour mark and am working on landings (well, they're
supposed to be landings but . . . well . . . lets just say I'm
thankful for sturdy landing gear).

I'm getting better at sideslipping during descent, but my instructor
and I have noticed some things that I'm doing on landing that are
really messing things up.

1) Too slow on approach (tendency to pull the yoke back as I get
closer to the ground).
2) Pulling back quickly on the level-off, causing a flare way too
early, with the resulting fun that happens after that.
3) Ending up on the left side of the runway and many times yawing to
the left.

I'm thinking that maybe 1 and 2 is caused by ground shyness. With the
nose down on what would probably be a proper approach, as we get down
close to the ground, it feels like I'm going to ram the nose of the
airplane into the ground. I know that I'm not (at least I know my
instructor will intervene before it gets to that point), but it makes
me very nervous. I'm unconciously pulling back on the yoke and don't
notice it until my instructor says "too slow -- nose down."

Anybody have any hints -- mental tricks if you will -- to get over
ground shyness. Or is it just do it over and over and I'll get used
to it.

Also, anybody have any idea about #3. It seems like I'm lined up and
everything, and next thing I know, I'm on the left side of the runway
again.

For the record, I'm flying a Piper Warrior II.



Back to top
James M. Knox
Guest





PostPosted: Thu Oct 21, 2004 1:54 pm    Post subject: Re: Ground shyness? Reply with quote

Bryan Mason <bmason wrote in
news:6p2dn0l02b7ivca62nqdrfsouk23243l8v (AT) 4ax (DOT) com:

Quote:
I'm thinking that maybe 1 and 2 is caused by ground shyness. With the
nose down on what would probably be a proper approach, as we get down
close to the ground, it feels like I'm going to ram the nose of the
airplane into the ground. I know that I'm not (at least I know my
instructor will intervene before it gets to that point), but it makes
me very nervous. I'm unconciously pulling back on the yoke and don't
notice it until my instructor says "too slow -- nose down."

Here's a thought... **if** the problem doesn't seem to be resolving
itself.

1. Standard drill... get yourself a nice LONG runway. Initially one
aligned with the wind (or no wind). Instructor along to keep everything
safe and keep an eye on things like the sides/end of hte runway, because
you are going to be busy elsewhere. Now, fly the approach and level out
as low over the runway as you feel comfortable. Now SLOWLY lower the
plane -- the idea is to fly the length of the runway with the wheels
just a few inches above, but not touching. The trick here is that you
have no rush to flare at just the right time, or touch down in the first
1000 feet - you've got 11,000 feet (or so) to play with.

2. Need something more specific... have the instructor take you up in a
Cessna 172 (feels fairly similar to a Warrior). You don't really need
to learn to fly the plane, just use it for the above exercise. The
difference to the above? With the instructor keeping the plane straight
down the runway (and safe) you concentrate ONLY on the height above the
runway BY LOOKING OUT THE SIDE WINDOW AT THE WHEEL. I know of know
better way to get that relationship between the sight picture out the
front vs. what the plane is actually doing. Every time you climb or
descend a couple of inches it will be VERY obvious.

Just my 2 cents...
jmk

Back to top
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    AirTalk.org Forum Index -> Aviation (Students) All times are GMT
Goto page 1, 2  Next
Page 1 of 2

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2006 phpBB Group
SEO toolkit © 2004-2006 webmedic.