 |
AirTalk.org Aviation discussions newsgroups
|
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Mika Koski Guest
|
Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2005 9:29 pm Post subject: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
Hi,
the sailplanes below are from www.segelflug.de and ones you can buy
with a (relatively) small amount of money, but they still are suitable
for crosscountry (L/D >= 35). The only plane among these I'm familiar
with is LS 4 controls-non-automatic-version so it will be kind of
benchmark for other planes.
Now I'm considering to buy one of listed planes for myself and for many
reasons my future plane will not be hangared, but kept in a trailer
when it is not used. From attaching and detaching* point of view, which
one would be optimal plane "to be taken out of the trailer in the
mornign and put back in the evening" usage?
ASW20
LS 3 & 4
Speed Astir II
DG-300
JANTAR
Std. Cirrus
Mistral C
If there is easy to attach/detach plane, which is not in the list and
you can buy it with less than 25000 EUR, please let me know.
Regards,
Mika Koski
Finland
* What is the right word in "soaring english" to be used for this?
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
kirk.stant@gmail.com Guest
|
Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2005 9:58 pm Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
LS4 is easy, even without automatic hookups - the LS sleeves make the
manual hookup of the ailerons and brakes quick and easy to check.
But that doesn't mean they can't be hooked up wrong! - I've managed to
incorrectly hook up a spoiler on an LS4-a, found by the positive check.
Oops...
LS4 wings are a bit heavy, but that builds character - and provides for
a nice fast redline!
Kirk
LS6-b "66"
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Mel Dawson Guest
|
Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2005 10:02 pm Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
At 21:30 17 November 2005, Mika Koski wrote:
| Quote: | Hi,
the sailplanes below are from www.segelflug.de and
ones you can buy
with a (relatively) small amount of money, but they
still are suitable
for crosscountry (L/D >= 35). The only plane among these
I'm familiar
with is LS 4 controls-non-automatic-version so it will
be kind of
benchmark for other planes.
Now I'm considering to buy one of listed planes for
myself and for many
reasons my future plane will not be hangared, but kept
in a trailer
when it is not used. From attaching and detaching*
point of view, which
one would be optimal plane 'to be taken out of the
trailer in the
mornign and put back in the evening' usage?
ASW20
LS 3 & 4
Speed Astir II
DG-300
JANTAR
Std. Cirrus
Mistral C
If there is easy to attach/detach plane, which is not
in the list and
you can buy it with less than 25000 EUR, please let
me know.
Regards,
Mika Koski
Finland
* What is the right word in 'soaring english' to be
used for this?
All modern gliders are 'easy' to rigg and de-rigg *
don't let this be a deciding factor.
|
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Shawn Guest
|
Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2005 10:20 pm Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
Mika Koski wrote:
| Quote: | Hi,
the sailplanes below are from www.segelflug.de and ones you can buy
with a (relatively) small amount of money, but they still are suitable
for crosscountry (L/D >= 35). The only plane among these I'm familiar
with is LS 4 controls-non-automatic-version so it will be kind of
benchmark for other planes.
Now I'm considering to buy one of listed planes for myself and for many
reasons my future plane will not be hangared, but kept in a trailer
when it is not used. From attaching and detaching* point of view, which
one would be optimal plane "to be taken out of the trailer in the
mornign and put back in the evening" usage?
ASW20
LS 3 & 4
Speed Astir II
DG-300
JANTAR
Std. Cirrus
Mistral C
If there is easy to attach/detach plane, which is not in the list and
you can buy it with less than 25000 EUR, please let me know.
|
Mosquito (Glasflugal 303). All the control connections are automatic.
The wing has a single pin and it goes together very easily.
Flys nicely too!
Shawn
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
matt@takestockphotos.com Guest
|
Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2005 10:46 pm Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
I've flown an LS-4 for the past four years. The hook-up is easy and
with collars that screw over the connection, is very difficult (but not
impossible) to attach incorrectly. I've learned to check the connection
by feeling the hole at the bottom of the control connection joint with
my finger. If the hole is a half-round, the connection is secure; if
you feel a completely round hole, the connection has not been made
correctly and you should start over. Rolladen-Schneider provides
mirrors to check the connections visually, but in my experience they
are useless.
Once you get used to rigging the glider, the whole process can be
accomplished in less than 15 minutes.
The LS-4 is also easy to fly and wonderfully forgiving of pilot errors
-- a good ship to begin with.
Matt
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Ray Lovinggood Guest
|
Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2005 11:10 pm Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
Mika,
I will repeat the message from Todd: It depends on
the trailer! All the difference is, mostly, in the
trailer! If the trailer is 'home built', it can be
good or bad, just depends on how it is set up. The
same is true for a factory trailer. Typically, the
factory trailers such as Cobra or Komet make assembly
and disassembly VERY easy.
All of your gliders on your list should be easy to
rig with a good trailer.
And also as mentioned, the 303 Mosquito has auto connections.
Ray Lovinggood
Carrboro, North Carolina, USA
At 21:30 17 November 2005, Mika Koski wrote:
| Quote: | Hi,
the sailplanes below are from www.segelflug.de and
ones you can buy
with a (relatively) small amount of money, but they
still are suitable
for crosscountry (L/D >= 35). The only plane among these
I'm familiar
with is LS 4 controls-non-automatic-version so it will
be kind of
benchmark for other planes.
Now I'm considering to buy one of listed planes for
myself and for many
reasons my future plane will not be hangared, but kept
in a trailer
when it is not used. From attaching and detaching*
point of view, which
one would be optimal plane 'to be taken out of the
trailer in the
mornign and put back in the evening' usage?
ASW20
LS 3 & 4
Speed Astir II
DG-300
JANTAR
Std. Cirrus
Mistral C
If there is easy to attach/detach plane, which is not
in the list and
you can buy it with less than 25000 EUR, please let
me know.
Regards,
Mika Koski
Finland
* What is the right word in 'soaring english' to be
used for this?
|
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Steve Leonard Guest
|
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2005 12:06 am Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
Not meaning to bag on them, but I have NEVER been around
an Astir of any kind that went together easily. I
am not a real fan of the 'twist to lock' front and
rear fittings. Someone, please tell me they can go
easy!
Of the rest, they can all be good. Get the seller
to walk you through assembling it and taking it apart.
You will get a real feel for how good the trailer
setup is when you do this one time. Most important
here is YOU do the work, with him telling you what
to do.
Glasflugels are really nice, since the have the bar
you can use to pull the wings together. As with any,
they must be in close alignment first, but you can
then pull them together. MUCH easier than telling
the person at the tip to 'wiggle and push in'. But
I think you will find that most that you are looking
at will just slide right together.
Have fun with whatever you buy!
Steve Leonard
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
toad Guest
|
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2005 1:29 am Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
Steve Leonard wrote:
| Quote: | Not meaning to bag on them, but I have NEVER been around
an Astir of any kind that went together easily. I
am not a real fan of the 'twist to lock' front and
rear fittings. Someone, please tell me they can go
easy!
|
Mine go real easy, in fact the whole glider rigs real easy.
I have the Std III, which was the lastest model made.
This is the most key advice, below.
| Quote: | Of the rest, they can all be good. Get the seller
to walk you through assembling it and taking it apart.
You will get a real feel for how good the trailer
setup is when you do this one time. Most important
here is YOU do the work, with him telling you what
to do.
|
My previous owner did this and I have had a great time rigging
ever since.
Have fun.
Todd
G102 Std III, 3S
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Andy Guest
|
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2005 1:48 am Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
The words I use are "rig" and "derig". From personal experience, and
observation of others, I'd say that gliders with spar tip pins that
mate in the other wing root are harder to rig than gliders that use 2
load bearing main spar pins. Other actors are wing weight, quality of
rigging aids, your experience, and the experience of your helper if you
use one.
You can learn to rig any glider and I don't think this should be a
major factor in making a selection.
Andy
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Greg Arnold Guest
|
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2005 2:05 am Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
Andy wrote:
| Quote: | The words I use are "rig" and "derig". From personal experience, and
observation of others, I'd say that gliders with spar tip pins that
mate in the other wing root are harder to rig than gliders that use 2
load bearing main spar pins.
|
Interesting. My experience has been just the opposite. It may be
initially easier to insert wings that take two pins, but you still have
to get everything lined up so you can insert the pins. By contrast, my
Discus slips right together (most of the time), and then all you have to
do is insert the one pin. It helps that the opening in the fuselage on
the spar tip side has a relatively small opening, so if you hit this
hole the spar tip pin should slip right into the other wing.
Other actors are wing weight, quality of
| Quote: | rigging aids, your experience, and the experience of your helper if you
use one.
You can learn to rig any glider and I don't think this should be a
major factor in making a selection.
Andy
|
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
hannu Guest
|
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2005 5:30 am Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
"Mika Koski" <mikakoski (AT) hotmail (DOT) com> wrote
| Quote: | Hi,
ASW20
LS 3 & 4
Speed Astir II
DG-300
JANTAR
Std. Cirrus
Mistral C
If there is easy to attach/detach plane, which is not in the list and
you can buy it with less than 25000 EUR, please let me know.
|
Hello Mika
Because this is an international group, let's keep this in English ;)
One glider maybe just in the price range might be SZD-55. It also has
automatic connections, the only remarkable thing in rigging is the tail main
pin security.
It's one of the most bang for buck (or euro).gliders.
Regarding rigging/de-rigging I wouldn't recommend Astir - flown one for
maaaaany years with too many outlandings ;)
regards
Hannu (currently flying SZD-55 "57")
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Chris Reed Guest
|
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2005 10:31 am Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
toad wrote:
| Quote: | Steve Leonard wrote:
Not meaning to bag on them, but I have NEVER been around
an Astir of any kind that went together easily. I
am not a real fan of the 'twist to lock' front and
rear fittings. Someone, please tell me they can go
easy!
And replied: |
| Quote: | Mine go real easy, in fact the whole glider rigs real easy.
I have the Std III, which was the lastest model made.
Toad is quite right, and I have regularly rigged an Astir with just |
myself and one helper (though the wings are on the heavy side).
The reason some people have problems is because they wiggle the wing.
This makes it almost certain that it won't slide into place. The key is
looking inside the cockpit to see that the pin on the end of the second
(port) wing is lined up with the hole in the first (starboard) wing. If
it is, all will slide into place (if you've greased all the pins). If
you can't line these up, the starboard wing tip is too high or too low.
A trestle for the starboard wingtip, and a belly dolly which doesn't
allow the fuselage to rotate, are probably the most useful things to have.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Kevin Brooker Guest
|
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2005 11:37 am Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
As said several times before, the trailer is everything for ease of
rig/de-rig. I've rigged the same model glider from differant trailers
and the effort required varied quite a lot. Any glider on your list is
fine; find the best set up trailer and buy that and take whatever is
inside. Great trailer set-ups make flying fun. A trailer that makes
you dread rigging/derigging will have you second guessing if you want
to risk using a crappy trailer in a field in the middle of the night.
Rig/derig on a gliderport is orders of magnitude differant then during
an off field landing. Putting the wings on is easy; getting the ship
safely in and out of the box is the real rub. Buy the trailer. Great
trailers make flying fun and will enhance the experiance. A good
trailer also makes it easier to find help rigging since the process
will be faster. You can fiddle w/ pins and such after the wings are on
and you've dismissed the help. FWIW, the LS-4 almost assembles itself;
if there is a good trailer.
On Fri, 18 Nov 2005 07:30:12 +0200, "hannu" <hn (AT) invalid (DOT) net> wrote:
| Quote: |
"Mika Koski" <mikakoski (AT) hotmail (DOT) com> wrote in message
news:1132262959.844144.94660 (AT) f14g2000cwb (DOT) googlegroups.com...
Hi,
ASW20
LS 3 & 4
Speed Astir II
DG-300
JANTAR
Std. Cirrus
Mistral C
If there is easy to attach/detach plane, which is not in the list and
you can buy it with less than 25000 EUR, please let me know.
Hello Mika
Because this is an international group, let's keep this in English ;)
One glider maybe just in the price range might be SZD-55. It also has
automatic connections, the only remarkable thing in rigging is the tail main
pin security.
It's one of the most bang for buck (or euro).gliders.
Regarding rigging/de-rigging I wouldn't recommend Astir - flown one for
maaaaany years with too many outlandings ;)
regards
Hannu (currently flying SZD-55 "57")
|
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
kirk.stant@gmail.com Guest
|
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2005 1:15 pm Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
Re two pin assembly vs one pin assembly; two main pins are really easy
if you know the trick to it. The big difference is that with a two pin
setup (LSs for examble), the wings go into the fuselage relatively
"loose", while single pin (Ventus, etc) wings have to fit into a
"tight" fuselage. This can cause some problems with newer single pin
gliders, until the exact right angle is found.
With a two pin, my technique is to put in the fork spar first, then the
tongue spar. Now, with the helper on the tip of the tongue spar wing,
have him lift the tip until the spar main pin holes on the side AWAY
from him (in the fuselage) line up, then insert that pin. This will
usually take a surprising amount of lift in an LS, by the way! Then
have him lower the tip until the pin holes closest to him are lined up,
and that pil will slide in easily.
What makes this easy in an LS is that until the first pin is in, the
wings are fairly loose in the fuselage and are easy to position.
This also works with ASW-20s, 19s, etc..
Works for me.
Kirk
LS6b 66
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
01-- Zero One Guest
|
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2005 1:45 pm Post subject: Re: Ease of attaching and detaching |
|
|
Kirk has properly pointed up the issue in trying to align 2 pin wings.
I cannot tell you how many even experienced owners still try to install
the pin nearest the helper first. Based on the geometry of the design,
the helper has very little ability to control the alignment on that pin
but can immediately effect change on the opposite one. Once the
opposite pin is installed then any vertical movement by the helper will
translate to the nearer pin receptacles.
Larry
"01" USA
LS-3a
"kirk.stant (AT) gmail (DOT) com" <kirk.stant (AT) gmail (DOT) com> wrote
| Quote: | Re two pin assembly vs one pin assembly; two main pins are really easy
if you know the trick to it. The big difference is that with a two pin
setup (LSs for examble), the wings go into the fuselage relatively
"loose", while single pin (Ventus, etc) wings have to fit into a
"tight" fuselage. This can cause some problems with newer single pin
gliders, until the exact right angle is found.
With a two pin, my technique is to put in the fork spar first, then the
tongue spar. Now, with the helper on the tip of the tongue spar wing,
have him lift the tip until the spar main pin holes on the side AWAY
from him (in the fuselage) line up, then insert that pin. This will
usually take a surprising amount of lift in an LS, by the way! Then
have him lower the tip until the pin holes closest to him are lined up,
and that pil will slide in easily.
What makes this easy in an LS is that until the first pin is in, the
wings are fairly loose in the fuselage and are easy to position.
This also works with ASW-20s, 19s, etc..
Works for me.
Kirk
LS6b 66
|
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|